If your company pays a Singapore-based vendor for consulting, management support, software, or any technical service, you probably deducted TDS at 10% under the India-Singapore DTAA. Here is the uncomfortable truth: in many of those cases, you may not have needed to withhold anything at all.
The India-Singapore DTAA is one of the most strategically important tax treaties in India’s network — and also one of the most misunderstood. The key is a four-word clause buried in Article 12(4): “make available technical knowledge.”
The Delhi High Court has repeatedly held that services failing this test are not taxable in India at all. In 2024 and 2025, both the Relx and Salesforce.com Singapore rulings clarified that subscription-based software and SaaS access do not satisfy “make available”. In 2025, the ITAT Mumbai held that ₹49.68 crore of management support fees paid to Tech Data Singapore were not taxable in India for the same reason.
If you are a finance controller, tax head, or business owner making payments to Singapore, this blog explains the make-available test, what documentation to collect, and where most Indian companies go wrong.
The Headline Rate: 10% TDS on FTS and Royalty
Under Article 12(2) of the India-Singapore DTAA, royalties and fees for technical services (FTS) paid by an Indian company to a Singapore resident are taxed at a maximum rate of 10% in India (gross basis). This is substantially lower than the domestic rate of 20% under Section 207(2) of the Income Tax Act, 2025 (earlier Section 115A of the Income Tax Act, 1961).
For a payment of ₹1 crore, this treaty rate means Indian TDS of ₹10 lakh instead of ₹20 lakh under domestic law — a direct ₹10 lakh saving on a single invoice.
But the 10% rate assumes the payment is actually taxable as FTS in India. That is where the make-available clause becomes critical.
What “Make Available” Actually Means
Article 12(4) of the India-Singapore DTAA defines “fees for technical services” narrowly. For a payment to qualify as FTS under the treaty, the services must meet one of three conditions:
(a) Be ancillary and subsidiary to the enjoyment of a right or property for which royalty is paid; OR
(b) Make available technical knowledge, experience, skill, know-how, or processes; OR
(c) Consist of the development and transfer of a technical plan or technical design.
Most cross-border service payments fall under condition (b) — the “make available” test. And this is where the treaty definition is significantly narrower than Indian domestic law.
The Test: Can the Indian Recipient Perform the Service Independently Afterward?
The Delhi High Court, Mumbai ITAT, and multiple other tribunals have laid down a consistent test. Technical knowledge is “made available” only when:
• The service provider transfers technical knowledge, skill, or processes to the Indian recipient; AND
• The recipient can apply that technology independently — without ongoing reliance on the service provider.
In the Relx Inc. case (2024), the Delhi HC held that giving a user access to a legal database does not transfer any technical skill. The user merely consumes the service — they do not acquire the ability to replicate the database themselves. The same logic was applied in the 2025 Salesforce.com Singapore ruling: CRM software subscriptions give users access to software, but do not make available the technology behind the software.
In the 2025 Tech Data Singapore ITAT ruling, management support fees of ₹49.68 crore were held non-taxable because the Indian entity received ongoing management advice but did not acquire the ability to perform those management functions on its own.
The 3-Scenario Rate Matrix for Singapore Payments
Based on the make-available test, Indian TDS on payments to Singapore vendors falls into three practical scenarios:
Scenario | India TDS Rate | Reason |
Service genuinely transfers technical know-how (e.g. training that leaves your team self-sufficient, licensed technical process, custom technical design) | 10% | Treaty FTS — Article 12(2) rate applies with TRC + Form 10F |
Service is ongoing advisory, management support, or ongoing consultancy where your team remains dependent on the provider | 0% (not taxable) | Does not make available technology; not FTS under treaty; falls under Article 7 business profits, no PE in India means no tax |
SaaS access or software subscription (CRM, database, cloud software) | 0% (not taxable) | Delhi HC in Relx and Salesforce: access to a platform is not royalty, not FTS, not “making available” technology |
Royalty (actual licence of copyrighted technical IP, trademark, patent, or formula) | 10% | Treaty royalty rate under Article 12(2) |
Equipment royalty (use of industrial, commercial, or scientific equipment) | 10% | Treaty rate under Article 12(2) — equipment-specific category |
A Real-World Example: ₹1 Crore Consulting Fee
An Indian manufacturing company pays ₹1 crore to a Singapore-based consulting firm for ongoing strategic business advice and management support throughout the year. How much TDS should be deducted?
Option 1 — Treat as FTS, apply 10%: Deduct ₹10 lakh. This is the default conservative approach most Indian CAs recommend.
Option 2 — Apply make-available test, deduct nil: If the consulting is ongoing advisory where the Indian team remains dependent on the Singapore firm, the service does not “make available” technical knowledge. It is not taxable as FTS under the treaty. It is taxable only as business profits under Article 7 — and since the Singapore firm has no PE in India, it is not taxable here at all. TDS: nil.
Option 2 is defensible — but only with proper documentation and legal analysis.
Documentation Checklist: What Your Singapore Vendor Must Provide
To claim the treaty rate (or nil withholding where applicable), your Singapore vendor must provide:
1. Tax Residency Certificate (TRC): Issued by the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (IRAS). Must be valid for the financial year in which payment is made. Mandatory under Section 159(8) of the Income Tax Act, 2025.
2. Form 10F: A self-declaration by the Singapore vendor confirming residency details not already in the TRC. Under the Income Tax Act, 2025, Form 10F must be filed electronically on the Indian income tax portal — which requires the foreign entity to have an Indian PAN. Foreign entities can apply for a PAN online.
3. No-PE declaration: Written declaration that the Singapore entity has no permanent establishment in India. If a PE exists, treaty rate protection falls away and the income is taxable as business profits.
4. Beneficial ownership declaration: Confirmation that the Singapore entity is the beneficial owner of the income, not merely a conduit. This is critical post-BEPS and under the Principal Purpose Test (PPT) in the India-Singapore Protocol.
5. Service contract: The underlying agreement, including a clear description of the services. This is what determines whether the make-available test is met.
The Form 10F Problem — And How to Solve It
The 2022 requirement that Form 10F must be filed online through the Indian income tax portal has created a real operational headache. The portal requires the foreign entity to first obtain an Indian PAN. Many Singapore companies, particularly SMEs, resist this because they have no other India tax filing obligation.
Options to resolve this:
• Encourage the Singapore vendor to obtain an Indian PAN (it is a one-time process, available online for foreign entities).
• In the interim, maintain a manual Form 10F in your records along with the TRC. CBDT has granted certain relaxations from time to time — verify the latest circular before relying on this.
• If treaty relief is challenged during scrutiny, be prepared to recover the differential TDS from the vendor.
Payment Compliance Timeline: 15CA, 15CB, Form 48 Mapping
Under the Income Tax Act, 2025 (in force from 1 April 2026), the governing provisions have changed names and numbers — but the underlying mechanics are the same:
• TDS obligation: Section 393(2) of the Income Tax Act, 2025 (earlier Section 195 of the 1961 Act).
• Treaty beneficial rate: Section 159(4) of the 2025 Act (earlier Section 90(2) of the 1961 Act) — taxpayer gets whichever is more beneficial, Act or treaty.
• Domestic rate for FTS: Section 207(2) of the 2025 Act (earlier Section 115A) — 20% gross.
• Form 15CA/15CB: Continue under the 2025 Act. Form 15CB (CA certificate) is required for taxable remittances above ₹5 lakh in a year. Form 15CA is filed by the remitter before the payment.
Common Mistakes Indian Companies Make
Mistake 1: Deducting 10% on everything paid to Singapore
The most common error. If the service does not meet the make-available test, 10% is excess withholding. The Singapore vendor will have to file an Indian return and claim a refund — a 12 to 18-month process.
Mistake 2: Ignoring the Principal Purpose Test (PPT)
Post the 2016 Protocol and BEPS Action 6, the India-Singapore DTAA incorporates the PPT. If the principal purpose of routing a transaction through Singapore is to obtain treaty benefits (with little real substance in Singapore), the benefit can be denied. Shell Singapore entities with no real operations remain under scrutiny.
Mistake 3: Treating SaaS payments as royalty
Software subscriptions, cloud access, and database access are not royalty following the Supreme Court’s Engineering Analysis judgment. Deducting TDS at 10% on a SaaS payment as royalty is incorrect — and the Singapore vendor may push back and recover the TDS from you.
Mistake 4: Not updating contract references to the Income Tax Act, 2025
Every intercompany agreement and vendor contract referencing Section 115A, Section 195, or Section 90 needs updating. The provisions are now 207, 393, and 159 respectively. Treasury systems, tax engines, and challans must reflect the new section numbers.
Why Chandigarh Businesses Should Care
Punjab and Chandigarh have a strong presence of IT services, pharma, agro-processing, and manufacturing businesses that engage Singapore vendors for cloud software, management consulting, and technology licensing. At PGA & Co., we regularly see Indian companies over-withholding by ₹5 to ₹15 lakh per year because they take the conservative 10% approach without applying the make-available test.
Equally, we see the opposite — companies deducting nil on genuine royalty payments because they confuse royalty with service fees. Both errors are expensive. Getting cross-border tax right requires a specific analysis of each vendor relationship.
Key Takeaways
• India-Singapore DTAA caps FTS/royalty at 10%, down from 20% domestic rate.
• Make-available test: FTS is taxable in India only if the service transfers technical knowledge that the Indian recipient can apply independently.
• SaaS and database access: Delhi HC has repeatedly held these do not meet make-available — not FTS, not royalty, not taxable.
• Ongoing management/advisory services: ITAT has consistently held these do not meet make-available — not FTS under treaty.
• Documentation is critical: TRC + Form 10F + No-PE declaration + beneficial ownership declaration + service contract.
• Income Tax Act, 2025: Sections 207, 393, and 159 now govern — update your contracts and systems.
• Form 10F online filing: Requires Indian PAN for the foreign vendor — operational pain point.
Making Cross-Border Payments? Get It Right.
Free 30-Minute Cross-Border Tax Consultation | Chandigarh & Pan-India
📞 +91 86998-87200 | 🌐 pgaca.in | 📧 info@pgaca.in
Frequently Asked Questions
Need expert guidance on this topic?
PGA & Co. Chartered Accountants can help. Speak with our team today.